The Multifaceted Nature of Old-Growth Forests

When most people envision old-growth forests, they think of towering, ancient trees that have withstood the test of time. However, the reality of these forests is far more intricate. The term "old-growth" does not conform to a single definition but varies dramatically across different climates and regions. While it does take a very long time to reach forest characteristics that we label as old-growth, there is more nuance to the developmental pathways that result in these forest structures - spatial and temporal variability in species, structure (crown classes/ stratums), composition, and legacies.

In temperate regions like North America's Pacific Northwest, old-growth forests are characterized by their massive, complex structures and diverse species assemblages. These forests are resilient, having survived a multitude of disturbances over centuries, resulting in a rich ecological tapestry. Conversely, old-growth in boreal forests may consist of dense stands of black spruce trees, mere meters tall but hundreds of years old, with peat bogs adding significant structural complexity to their environment.

Old-growth in the Pacific Northwest. *Photo: Tristan Goodbody*

Black spruce grow in the 13,000 year old Tannersville Cranberry Bog in Pennslyvania. *Photo: Kat Bolus / WVIA*

Stages of Forest Growth

Understanding the development of forests can help us understand the complexity we see in old-growth. Theories for forest succession are often broken down into one of two progressions—one is a relatively simplistic 4-stage flow and the other a more detailed 8-stage flow:

4-Stage:
1. Stand Initiation - Begins after a disturbance, with rapid colonization by pioneer species, high seedling density, and intense competition.
2. Stem Exclusion - Self-thinning due to intense competition, leading to canopy formation and suppression of understory vegetation.
3. Understory Reinitiation - Canopy gaps allow light to reach the forest floor, promoting growth of shade-tolerant species and increasing forest structural complexity.
4. Old-Growth - A mature, stable forest with large trees, multi-layered canopy, high biodiversity, and significant composition of coarse wood.

8-Stage :
1. Disturbance and Legacy Creation - Vary in type, size, intensity, frequency, and homogeneity - influence rate of composition and density of tree region.
2. Cohort establishment - Variable in duration and eventual stocking - influenced by disturbance severity/intensity, environmental conditions (drought/competition).
3. Canopy closure - Can be a brief transitional stage - highly dramatic developmental change, rapid on productive sites.
4. Biomass accumulation/competitive exclusion - Rapid growth and biomass accumulation, intense competition.
5. Maturation - Individual height and crown spread occurs in dominant individuals, canopy thins, coarse wood low, understory beings to re-establish.
6. Vertical diversification - Shade tolerant cohort establishment and growth, lower crown growth. Gap phase dynamics continue to increase spatial heterogeneity.
7. Horizontal diversification - Continued spatially aggregated gap dynamics.
8. Pioneer cohort loss - Death of large trees can cause legacy development that are available for many centuries.

Management of Old-Growth Forests

This diversity presents substantial management challenges as old-growth forests require a profound understanding of their unique complexities and subtle differences. Foresters are tasked with recognizing and facilitating the natural processes that contribute to this complexity, ensuring that the forest’s development reflects the characteristics of old growth. Management strategies must be carefully crafted to support the forest's health and growth. Techniques such as selective harvesting and strategic thinning are not simply about enhancing growth rates; they are vital for encouraging the emergence of new plant generations. These practices are tailored to meet the specific needs of each forest, with a constant eye toward long-term ecological goals. For example, a forest manager must envision the forest’s future state a century ahead and implement practices today that will sculpt tomorrow’s ecosystem. By fostering conditions that promote structural complexity and biodiversity, we not only conserve these ancient forests but also enhance their role in supporting a strong ecological network for the future.

The government of British Columbia has presented a hopeful model for progressive changes to old growth management. They recently initiated a new forest stewardship strategy through the "Old Growth Strategic Review" report, A New Future for Old Forests, which includes 14 recommendations focused on collaborative efforts with First Nations, industry, and local communities. The action plan organizes these recommendations into three main goals: expanding inclusive land governance, fostering stewardship for healthy ecosystems, and supporting systemic changes. This approach aims to ensure the resilience and health of old-growth forests for future generations.

Despite these efforts, challenges have still risen. The BC NDP government has claimed significant progress in protecting old-growth forests, but ecological reports indicating that less than three percent of B.C.'s most biodiverse old-growth forests are still standing. The urgency of these reports led to a strategic review that recommended immediate logging deferrals to prevent biodiversity loss, but implementation has been partial at best. This has sparked substantial protests, including at Fairy Creek, where over 1,100 protesters were arrested amid disputes over logging practices and old-growth forest conservation. Despite a court highlighting concerns about civil liberties during these protests, enforcement actions continued. Adding to the chaos, the B.C. government temporarily paused old-growth logging following requests from local First Nations developing stewardship plans, aiming to balance conservation efforts, indigenous rights, and logging interests. However, ongoing protests and slow reforms indicate persistent conflicts in managing B.C.'s old-growth forests.

Economic Perspectives

Old-growth forests often find themselves at the intersection of conservation efforts and the lucrative logging industry. The short-term financial benefits of harvesting these forests stand in stark contrast to the long-term advantages they offer, including ecosystem services like biodiversity preservation, cultural-heritage, and eco-tourism opportunities. Economic incentives, such as carbon financing, provide a compelling method to promote sustainable management practices for “working forests”. These financial frameworks encourage foresters to develop and implement management strategies that aim for a maturity resembling old growth, thus balancing developmental and conservation needs.

Social Implications

The significance of old-growth forests extend beyond their ecological benefits, touching the lives of local communities. These forests are more than just sources of timber or carbon sinks; they are integral to the cultural heritage and traditional practices of indigenous and local populations. The increasing integration of these traditional knowledge systems into forest management is crucial not only for preserving biodiversity but also for supporting socio-economic stability. By adopting governance models that uphold procedural equity, we can ensure that forest conservation and management is collaborative, inclusive, and constructive.

The Native Kwiakah people illustrate this social significance in their effort to preserve Great Bear Rainforest. Although small with only 21 members, the Kwiakah First Nation is actively engaged in preserving the Great Bear Rainforest through the creation of the M̓ac̓inuxʷ Special Forest Management Area, spanning 7,865 hectares. Chief Steven Dick envisions a future where the territory remains protected and abundant, supporting not only the wildlife but also providing jobs and a research center for Indigenous-led conservation. This area, one of nine in the Great Bear Rainforest, focuses on regenerative forestry to restore the forest to its pre-industrial state and shares these sustainable practices with other nations. This initiative aligns with broader efforts by the B.C. government to update old growth management, including increasing logging revenue shares and developing stewardship programs with First Nations, aiming to meet modern societal expectations and address the urgent needs posed by climate change.

Ecological & Environmental Significance

Old-growth forests stand unmatched in their biodiversity and structural complexity. The varied structural features of these forests, from towering canopies to rich undergrowths, create a mosaic of habitats that support a diverse array of species. These ecosystems are shaped by centuries of natural processes, including disturbances that spur regeneration and bolster resilience. The ecological health of these forests is crucial not only for the species that inhabit them but also for the overall functioning of our planet’s biological systems.

The role of old-growth forests in regulating the climate is critical. Their extensive above and below ground biomass and soils serve as significant carbon stores, mitigating the impact of climate change by sequestering and holding carbon dioxide. Furthermore, their robust structures provide resilience against natural disasters such as fires and storms, maintaining ecological balance. The preservation of these forests is vital for sustaining our global environment, offering a natural solution to some of the most pressing environmental challenges we face today.

Conclusion

Old-growth forests represent a convergence of economic value, cultural heritage, ecological diversity, and environmental protection. Understanding and managing these forests through an integrated ecosystem-based management approach that respects local traditional values is key. We also need to ensure that management approaches align with both local and global conservation goals. As we continue to confront global environmental challenges, the preservation of old-growth forests emerge as a crucial strategy for maintaining the health of our planet and the well-being of its inhabitants.

‍

Sources:

‍

Share this post